How fast did the previous owner say the boat could go? What does the seller tell you? Will the seller, the dealer or the previous owner allow you to have a test drive to confirm its speed and its acceleration prior to your purchase? I know it's tempting to speculate about your future boat's speed using information from Bennington owners with similar boats (and to be sure, I believe such information from others can be very valuable--in fact, I think the predictions above are probably very accurate, especially Daril's prediction, since he owns a nearly identical boat with a nearly identical engine) but I would still recommend test driving the boat prior to your purchase if that is possible.
I had a similar problem to yours. I knew what boat I wanted (a 2014 2375 GCW) and what engine I wanted (an F-150 HP Yamaha), and several people told me how fast they thought the boat would go. But no matter what people told me, I still could not shake my uncertainty about its performance until I had a chance to test drive the boat myself. Even though I had officially signed to purchase the boat, my inability to reassure myself about its speed and handling was very uncomfortable for me, and I knew I was going to have to live with this uncomfortable feeling from November though mid-April until I would take delivery of the boat in 2014. So, my dealer, a wonderful man, recognizing my anxiety, allowed me to test drive an identical pontoon boat. It only went 37 MPH (I had been used to 50 MPH on my SeaRay 210) but since I am now much older, I was very happy with its speed and its handling, and as a result, I was able to calm all my nervousness about my purchase. Now I feel much more comfortable waiting for the delivery in mid-April. I am soooo excited now, but not at all nervous any more.
By the way, I think you are making a great choice in the boat you mentioned. And my personal opinion is that you will break 40 MPH and that you will be very happy. But had you told us the HP of the engine it would have allowed our predictions to be more accurate. (I had a 5.0L Mercury I/O and it was only rated for for 210 HP back in 1996, but I know that some of the 5.0L engines are modified to reach much higher HP than mine was.)
David