On a super calm, no wave kinda day, I would be REALLY interested to see video of the under deck through the whole acceleration phase. I don't want to say "it's the sea legs fault" like mechanics used to do about aftermarket command start when it first came out (really funny story I can tell if you want), but I just don't know enough about the sea leg product.
The thought in my head is I wonder if the prop IS getting good bite in the water, but the turmoil under the deck of water hitting the sea legs is bogging the motor, similar too when you have a full boat load of people. So not necessarily a bogging sound, like when using a 12" post hole digger in thick wet clay like I've been doing all weekend, but just topping out.
Once again, I am probably about the LEAST experienced person on here with regards to props as I was pleased with the performance of each that originally came with my boat. Well maybe not on my 90hp, nothing pleased me about it except for being on the water, although in '09 I was still passing a lot of toons with 60's and 75's on them. I also have ZERO experience with sea legs, I love the idea of them and think it would be great if a manufacturer figured out a way to incorporate them in the factory with something like a sloped underskinning from the front and have them completely inset into the underskinning to reduce the drag issues, which I think would make them awesome.
Once again, I really have NO idea, these are all just thoughts rolling around in my head. Is there anyone around you that has a similar setup that you could compare to?
I do agree that the 16 might be a bit much, my 200 I think was a 15 and my 250 a 17, but not sure.