Was it Rubber Ducky boat rentals? If you're ever down this way let me know. Lighthouse Harbor is also on the lake and they rent Benningtons.Welcome aboard! Wonderful people here!
I rented a pontoon on Wallenpaupack several years back. Talk about a beat up boat!!! There were a couple of plastic patio chairs screwed to the deck. The lady at the rental desk asked if I wanted to actually take the anchor. It's a good thing I did, as the engine's oil alarm went off just as we got past the island at the NE corner. Had to wait for the rental people to come out with some oil for us. Turned out not as fun as we had hoped.
One of these days I may bring my boat down to that beautiful lake, with the anchor!!!!!!
Wow, I didn't realize it was that big of a lake. You will love your Benni on it! Again, welcome to the family.13 miles long (52 miles of shoreline) about 60' at the deepest point. The only picture I have is of what I took off the dealerships website (before the motor was installed) but not sure how to post pictures here yet.